The best auto insurance companies in Minnesota
There's no single 'best' insurer — only the best fit for your record, vehicles, and budget. Here's an honest look at the major carriers Minnesota drivers actually use, and where each one tends to shine.
| Carrier | Best for | Claims | Accident forgiveness | SR-22 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| State Farm | Local agent service, bundling | Strong, large MN agent network | Available in many cases | Yes |
| American Family | Minnesota-based, bundling | Strong regional service | Available | Yes |
| Auto-Owners | Service through independent agents | Consistently high marks | Available | Varies |
| Progressive | Higher-risk drivers, comparison | Good, tech-forward | Available (loyalty-based) | Yes |
| Travelers | Bundling, accident forgiveness | Solid | Available as add-on | Yes |
| AAA (The Auto Club Group) | Members, roadside | Solid, member-focused | Available | Varies |
| Allstate | Add-ons and feature options | Average to good | Available | Yes |
| Geico | Low base rates, direct buyers | Efficient, mostly direct | Available as add-on | Yes |
| Minnesota mutuals & regionals | Greater MN, rural drivers | Often excellent locally | Varies | Varies |
State Farm
The largest auto insurer in Minnesota. Deep local agent presence and the Drive Safe & Save telematics program. Often competitive for clean-record households that bundle.
American Family
Headquartered in the Upper Midwest with a strong Minnesota footprint and KnowYourDrive telematics. Frequently competitive when bundled with home.
Auto-Owners
Sold only through independent agents. Known for claims satisfaction and steady pricing — a strong option for drivers who want an agent shopping multiple carriers.
Progressive
Often competitive for drivers with tickets or lapses, and easy to compare. Snapshot telematics can help or hurt depending on driving habits.
Travelers
Competitive multi-policy pricing and a range of endorsements, including accident forgiveness and new-car replacement on eligible vehicles.
AAA (The Auto Club Group)
Membership perks and strong roadside assistance. Pricing is most attractive for existing AAA members who bundle.
Allstate
Wide menu of features (Drivewise telematics, accident forgiveness, deductible rewards). Base rates can run higher; discounts matter.
Geico
Frequently low base premiums for clean records who are comfortable managing things online. Less local-agent support than the regional carriers.
Minnesota mutuals & regionals
Smaller Minnesota mutual and regional insurers can be very competitive in greater Minnesota, especially for rural risks and multi-line farm/auto bundles. Availability is local.
Request a personalized Minnesota auto insurance review.
Share a few details about your vehicles, drivers, and current coverage. A licensed Minnesota insurance professional will compare options and walk you through what we find.