AutoInsuranceMN.com
Full Coverage Worth-It Calculator

Is full coverage still worth it on your car?

Collision and comprehensive pay to fix or replace your own car — but they can only ever pay your car's value minus the deductible. As a vehicle ages, that potential payout shrinks while the premium often doesn't. Here's the math for your car.

Your inputs
Estimated results
The verdict
Consider dropping
Most you could ever collect
$5,250
Annual cost
$900
Premium as a share of max payout
17%
A common guideline: when the annual cost exceeds about 10% of the most you could collect, dropping collision and comprehensive often makes sense — especially if you could replace the car yourself.

Want a licensed Minnesota insurance professional to review these numbers against your actual policy? Request a free, no-obligation review.

Get My Minnesota Auto Quote

How it works. The most collision/comprehensive can ever pay is your car's value minus the deductible. We compare your annual cost against that ceiling. The higher the ratio, the less you're getting for your premium.

Minnesota note. Comprehensive also covers deer strikes, hail, and theft — real risks here. If your car is older but you can't easily replace it after a deer strike, that can tip the decision toward keeping coverage even when the pure math is marginal.

This is a planning estimate, not advice. Liability, PIP, and UM/UIM are separate — this tool is only about collision and comprehensive on your own vehicle.

Free, no obligation

Request a personalized Minnesota auto insurance review.

Share a few details about your vehicles, drivers, and current coverage. A licensed Minnesota insurance professional will compare options and walk you through what we find.

Keep reading